Let me preemptively state this fact for some kind of insurance against vilification from Gleeks: I don’t watch Glee, so there’s a very real chance that I don’t know what I’m about to talk about in regards to the actual episode at hand. I only saw the first season, and then I quit watching because it became so ridiculous that my brain exploded a little bit more with every new episode (which is to say that I’m being dramatic and it just wasn’t my cup of tea). Please forgiveth any recap errors.
That being said, I like to keep up-to-date on the goings-on of this show, because it tends to incite public controversy amongst media representatives who are under the presumption that Glee apparently singlehandedly shapes the opinions of every impressionable adolescent on Earth, or something. And Glee-related controversies arise frequently, because literally every hour-long segment of that show is a goddamn Very Special Episode.
Homosexuality? Gasp! Premarital sex? Gasp! Teen pregnancy? Gasp! Our children can’t be exposed to these concepts, because otherwise they’ll try to be like all the cool kids on Glee and go and get themselves teen-pregnant! Really, I’m more concerned about the liberal usage of auto-tune on that show, but whatever. (Also, that whole plotline where Quinn tried to steal her biological daughter, Beth, back from the adoptive mother was ridiculous and could’ve easily been foiled in two seconds if any other character had bothered to remind Quinn that she voluntarily relinquished legal right to custody of Beth months ago. The entire storyline neglected to acknowledge basically every reality of the adoption process in the first place. But I digress.)
Anyway, in last night’s episode, Quinn got into a car accident on the way to Rachel and Finn’s wedding (WTF? Aren’t they like 18?), and she might be dead, or some shit. Whatever. She’s a fictional character with a fairly weak singing voice, who probably isn’t even dead anyway. I think I’ll recover. What caught my attention after seeing some shocked Facebook statuses and perusing the internet for episode recaps was the fact that in last night’s episode, a supporting character—Dave Karofsky, the closeted homosexual/football butthead-jerkface who bullied Kurt for being gay—attempted suicide after enduring persistent bullying for the same reason.
Suicide rates are much higher in LGBTQ teens, and the obvious explanation for this unfortunate statistic is that queer teens are likelier to be bullied and lack self-acceptance on the basis of their sexual orientation than heterosexual teens are. But depression and suicide are much more complicated than that reasoning alone, and to put it in those terms oversimplifies the actual problems.
Approximately 1 in 8 teens are experiencing clinical depression at any given time, and 1 in 5 experience depression at some point before reaching adulthood. One of the scariest things about depression is that, particularly for adolescents (who are still in the process of forming their identities and are especially sensitive to negative social treatment), mental illness is so stigmatized that it is frequently undiagnosed, disregarded, and untreated in its sufferers, who remain undereducated about their own conditions—conditions that, under these circumstances, inevitably worsen.
However, when shows like Glee succumb to the “It Gets Better” effect and ignore the reality that depression is not entirely causal—that is to say, that sometimes it happens for no reason at all, because it is an illness, not just a feeling—they dangerously ignore the huge number of people who suffer from depression/suicidal impulses and have no clear-cut answer to their pain. And, in fact, nobody with a mental illness has a clear-cut answer or solution. Depression may manifest itself in personal experiences, but in this case, correlation does not equal causation. Some people endure torture-filled years of bullying and barrages of bad luck and manage to cope and recover, whereas many other people share similar experiences and develop severe depression. Some people walk around everyday with unbearable sadness and never attempt or even consider suicide, but many other people with the same pain feel that they are unable to cope with living.
The point here is that mental illness doesn’t have crystal-clear explanations, ever. You can’t tell a kid “it gets better” and expect that this attempted glimmer of hope will cure an illness. It is intolerable that popular culture is condescendingly treating depression and suicidal tendencies as a “feeling” rather than a disease, because to do so only further stigmatizes people with these traits—the vast majority of whom aren’t cured by three words or happy stories, and who very likely feel a great amount of shame when these supposed cures do nothing to fix their pain at all.
The “It Gets Better Project”—created as an attempt to reduce the high rates of suicide in GLBTQ teens—and its resulting messages are entirely well-intentioned, but they aren’t helpful in the long term to people with suicidal tendencies. Teens with depression don’t need to be told that their futures will brighten if they wait the pain out. They need to be informed of ways to seek help right now.
So yeah, Glee. I commend its attempt to address suicide and the bullying that queer teens have to endure in a serious manner, but I condemn its ignorance and lack of substance/helpfulness/reality. I don’t give half a damn about that show, but right now, it’s proving to be a pretty effective example of the oversimplification of the very serious and all-too-common tragedy of suicide.
This article focuses on depression, but clinical depression is far from the only factor in determining teen suicide. However, it is generally believed to be the most common one. Depression is an illness, and having a serotonin shortage is no more shameful than having a cold. If you’re suffering from symptoms of depression or another mental illness, please do not hesitate to get help immediately. Talk to a parent, a friend, a sibling, a doctor, a teacher, or even inbox me if you need support. You don’t have to be this sad anymore, and it’s not even the tiniest bit your fault. Reach out for help (untapped resources abound you), and you can be a hero to yourself and to others who haven’t yet found the same courage.



